CMPRISON OF KRTICHAKRA WITH OTHER MLTRY MS. SCAND CM REV-P13 - Page 3

Aravind Mohan Krishnan · 09-03-2006, 03:54 PM

Fine Hishamem. U say whatever u want. No point in arguing with you as it will be rather pointless..

jaseer · 09-03-2006, 03:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HISHAMEM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deepak

Hi friends, nice topic. But I dont think KC can be compared to NS. Nair Saab is not at all a military movie. It is just a film taken in a military background. It doesnt deal with the actual problems that our nation is facing. Its a masala mix, remember the comedy scenes of Mukesh and party. Such scenes can be seen in overproportion in NS. Maybe they did that eyeing commercial success. But KC is a film that deals exclusively with the issue of terrorism. The film successfully gives the viewer a description of the situation in Kashmir and the problems faced by the soldiers. The dialogues are also very revealing, for example, there is this dialogue by a terrorist 'We dont consider Indian muslims as muslims'. Such dialogues are really crisp and the viewer can identify with the film easily. NS doesnt have even a single dialogue that is touchy. We dont get a feeling of patriotism after watching NS. In KC the guns and machinery used are original. We can feel the difference in action scenes. The encounter scenes are perfect lasting no more than 3-4 minutes. In terms of action scenes NS is just average. Nothing new about it. Performance wise, i think Mohanlal and Mammoty are on par. But Mohanlal can be better than Mammoty in action scenes as we all know that Mammoty cannot match Mohanlal in stunts. Before the movie was released Mammoty fans were booing Mohanlal saying that he cant do such a role. But Mohanlal came up with an excellent performance. He handles all the languages with ease and his dialogue delivery is fantastic. And about the bulky physique of Mohanlal, we have to remember that military is not about appearance. Its all about intelligence and quickness. Mohanlal was very fast in his encounter movements. So there is no point crtitisising him on his physique. Remember that the physicaly fit Mammoty didnt do anything better in action scenes of NS compared to Mohanlal in KC. And the success of KC is more superior to that of NS. Remember that in KC except Mohanlal there is no other prominent malayalam star who are crowd pullers. But NS is packed with prominent stars like Mukesh, Suresh, LaluALex, Devan, Raju etc. On the whole, NS cannot be compared to KC. KC is rooted in reality much more than NS.

WHAT U MEAN BY PROMINENT STARS.ON WHAT BASIS U ARE TELLING MUKESH , SURESHGOPI LALU ALEX ARE PROMINENT ACTORS THAN JEEVA, BIJU MENON , SHAMMITTHILAKAN, COCHIN HANEEFA , SAIKUMAR. PLEASE AVOID THIS TYPE OF RUBBISH COMMENTS. EVN KEERTHI CHAKRA HAVING SOME UNNECESSARY MASALA SCENES ( UNNECESSARY RAPE SCENES) AND SOME UNWANTED FIGHTS KEERTHICHAKRA'S TAMIL REMAKE FAILED IN TAMIL BOX OFFICE WHEREAS WHEN NAAIRSAAB DUBBED IN TAMIL, IT WAS BIG HIT. THAT MEANS TAMILANS APPRECIATED JOSHI'S TECHNICAL PERFECTION THAN THAT OF MAJOR RAVI. AND THAT OF MAMOOTY'S ACTING THAN MOHANLAL . EVEN MOHANLAL'S BIBLE SIFY CRITICISED THAT VULGAR RAPE SCENE IN KEERTHICHAKRA

NEW DELHI STORY POLE MATTORU STTOOORY ...
POOYI THOOONGI CHAKEDAAAAAAAAAAAAA NANAMILLATHAVANEEEEEEEEEE..

MAMMUVINTE 2 FILM --MILITORY BACKGROUNDIL EDUTHU ..NAIRSAB / SAINYAM

ONNU HITAAYI --ONNU KEERI PALESAYI ...2 UM MAAS MASALA FILM ..

ATHINEYAANO NEE KEERTIYUMAAYI COMPAIRE CHEYYUNNATHU ..

KEERHTI MASS FILM ALLA . INIYUM NINNOD ENTHELUM PARAYAAN NINNAL-
POTHINTE CHEVIYIL VEDHAM ODUNATHU POLEYAAKUM ..

Aravind Mohan Krishnan · 09-03-2006, 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jaseer

Quote:

Originally Posted by HISHAMEM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deepak

Hi friends, nice topic. But I dont think KC can be compared to NS. Nair Saab is not at all a military movie. It is just a film taken in a military background. It doesnt deal with the actual problems that our nation is facing. Its a masala mix, remember the comedy scenes of Mukesh and party. Such scenes can be seen in overproportion in NS. Maybe they did that eyeing commercial success. But KC is a film that deals exclusively with the issue of terrorism. The film successfully gives the viewer a description of the situation in Kashmir and the problems faced by the soldiers. The dialogues are also very revealing, for example, there is this dialogue by a terrorist 'We dont consider Indian muslims as muslims'. Such dialogues are really crisp and the viewer can identify with the film easily. NS doesnt have even a single dialogue that is touchy. We dont get a feeling of patriotism after watching NS. In KC the guns and machinery used are original. We can feel the difference in action scenes. The encounter scenes are perfect lasting no more than 3-4 minutes. In terms of action scenes NS is just average. Nothing new about it. Performance wise, i think Mohanlal and Mammoty are on par. But Mohanlal can be better than Mammoty in action scenes as we all know that Mammoty cannot match Mohanlal in stunts. Before the movie was released Mammoty fans were booing Mohanlal saying that he cant do such a role. But Mohanlal came up with an excellent performance. He handles all the languages with ease and his dialogue delivery is fantastic. And about the bulky physique of Mohanlal, we have to remember that military is not about appearance. Its all about intelligence and quickness. Mohanlal was very fast in his encounter movements. So there is no point crtitisising him on his physique. Remember that the physicaly fit Mammoty didnt do anything better in action scenes of NS compared to Mohanlal in KC. And the success of KC is more superior to that of NS. Remember that in KC except Mohanlal there is no other prominent malayalam star who are crowd pullers. But NS is packed with prominent stars like Mukesh, Suresh, LaluALex, Devan, Raju etc. On the whole, NS cannot be compared to KC. KC is rooted in reality much more than NS.

WHAT U MEAN BY PROMINENT STARS.ON WHAT BASIS U ARE TELLING MUKESH , SURESHGOPI LALU ALEX ARE PROMINENT ACTORS THAN JEEVA, BIJU MENON , SHAMMITTHILAKAN, COCHIN HANEEFA , SAIKUMAR. PLEASE AVOID THIS TYPE OF RUBBISH COMMENTS. EVN KEERTHI CHAKRA HAVING SOME UNNECESSARY MASALA SCENES ( UNNECESSARY RAPE SCENES) AND SOME UNWANTED FIGHTS KEERTHICHAKRA'S TAMIL REMAKE FAILED IN TAMIL BOX OFFICE WHEREAS WHEN NAAIRSAAB DUBBED IN TAMIL, IT WAS BIG HIT. THAT MEANS TAMILANS APPRECIATED JOSHI'S TECHNICAL PERFECTION THAN THAT OF MAJOR RAVI. AND THAT OF MAMOOTY'S ACTING THAN MOHANLAL . EVEN MOHANLAL'S BIBLE SIFY CRITICISED THAT VULGAR RAPE SCENE IN KEERTHICHAKRA

NEW DELHI STORY POLE MATTORU STTOOORY ...
POOYI THOOONGI CHAKEDAAAAAAAAAAAAA NANAMILLATHAVANEEEEEEEEEE..

MAMMUVINTE 2 FILM --MILITORY BACKGROUNDIL EDUTHU ..NAIRSAB / SAINYAM

ONNU HITAAYI --ONNU KEERI PALESAYI ...2 UM MAAS MASALA FILM ..

ATHINEYAANO NEE KEERTIYUMAAYI COMPAIRE CHEYYUNNATHU ..

KEERHTI MASS FILM ALLA . INIYUM NINNOD ENTHELUM PARAYAAN NINNAL-
POTHINTE CHEVIYIL VEDHAM ODUNATHU POLEYAAKUM ..

Patallam can be added too

GK · 09-03-2006, 04:01 PM

Fair enough. There are a lot of Mallus in KC. But its a Malayalam military film. What do u expect? The army batch is mixed with Mallus and Tamilians and the villains are Afghanis and Kashmiris. If u point out Sanusha is a Malayalee than what is there for the two leading ladies (Lizzie is one..) in Nair Saab. Will a daughter of a brigadier go with him to Kashmir? In most cases I dont think so. More appropriate is Jeeva's case where his entire family stays in Chennai (they speak Tamil as should be)

`````````````````````````````````````````````````` `````````````````````````````````````````````````` `````HI ARAVIND
There are a lot of Mallus in KC. But its a Malayalam military film. What do u expect?--------SAME ALSO HAPPENED IN NAIR SAAB ALSO. THEN WHY U CRITICISED MALAYALEE OFFICERS IN NAIR SAAB
If u point out Sanusha is a Malayalee than what is there for the two leading ladies (Lizzie is one..) in Nair Saab-----------IN THE PICTUR SHOWING SHANUSHA AS KASHMIRI, IT IS TOO DIFFICULT TO BELIEVE A KAHSMIRI GIRL SPEAKING MALAYALAM THIS MUCH FLUENCY.
THAT OF LIZZY , SHE IS SISTER OF DEVAN, A MALAYALEE BUSINESS MAN. WHAT'S WRONG IN MALAYALEES SPEAKING MALAYALAM

Will a daughter of a brigadier go with him to Kashmir? In most cases I dont think so.---WHAT'S WRONG IN TOP OFFICIAL AND HIS FAMILY STAYING WITH THEIR FAMILY IN KASHMIR

More appropriate is Jeeva's case where his entire family stays in Chennai (they speak Tamil as should be)----JEEVA IS ONLY A SMALL OFFICER IN KEERTHICHAKRA. IF U DONT KNOW THAT PLEASE WATCH KEERTHICHAKRA AGAIN THEN U WILL COME TO REALISE THIS FACT. THAT'S WAY JEEVA AND FAMILY STAYING IN TAMILNADU. AND MOHANLAL AND HIS FAMILY STAYING IN KASHMIR ALSO SHOWING IN KEERHICHAKRA. THE REASON IS MOHANLAL TOP OFFICLA LIKE THAT OF JAGNATH VARMA IN NAIRSAAB

The army batch is mixed with Mallus and Tamilians and the villains are Afghanis and Kashmiris-ON WHAT BASIS U ARE TELLING TERRORISTS ARE ALWYS AFGHANS AND KSHMIRIS. THER ARE LOT OF TERRORIST IN OUR COUNTRY ALSO SPEAKING DIFFERNT LANGUAGES CAME FROM SOME OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES ETC

jaseer · 09-03-2006, 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aravind Mohan Krishnan

Quote:

Originally Posted by jaseer

Quote:

Originally Posted by HISHAMEM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deepak

Hi friends, nice topic. But I dont think KC can be compared to NS. Nair Saab is not at all a military movie. It is just a film taken in a military background. It doesnt deal with the actual problems that our nation is facing. Its a masala mix, remember the comedy scenes of Mukesh and party. Such scenes can be seen in overproportion in NS. Maybe they did that eyeing commercial success. But KC is a film that deals exclusively with the issue of terrorism. The film successfully gives the viewer a description of the situation in Kashmir and the problems faced by the soldiers. The dialogues are also very revealing, for example, there is this dialogue by a terrorist 'We dont consider Indian muslims as muslims'. Such dialogues are really crisp and the viewer can identify with the film easily. NS doesnt have even a single dialogue that is touchy. We dont get a feeling of patriotism after watching NS. In KC the guns and machinery used are original. We can feel the difference in action scenes. The encounter scenes are perfect lasting no more than 3-4 minutes. In terms of action scenes NS is just average. Nothing new about it. Performance wise, i think Mohanlal and Mammoty are on par. But Mohanlal can be better than Mammoty in action scenes as we all know that Mammoty cannot match Mohanlal in stunts. Before the movie was released Mammoty fans were booing Mohanlal saying that he cant do such a role. But Mohanlal came up with an excellent performance. He handles all the languages with ease and his dialogue delivery is fantastic. And about the bulky physique of Mohanlal, we have to remember that military is not about appearance. Its all about intelligence and quickness. Mohanlal was very fast in his encounter movements. So there is no point crtitisising him on his physique. Remember that the physicaly fit Mammoty didnt do anything better in action scenes of NS compared to Mohanlal in KC. And the success of KC is more superior to that of NS. Remember that in KC except Mohanlal there is no other prominent malayalam star who are crowd pullers. But NS is packed with prominent stars like Mukesh, Suresh, LaluALex, Devan, Raju etc. On the whole, NS cannot be compared to KC. KC is rooted in reality much more than NS.

WHAT U MEAN BY PROMINENT STARS.ON WHAT BASIS U ARE TELLING MUKESH , SURESHGOPI LALU ALEX ARE PROMINENT ACTORS THAN JEEVA, BIJU MENON , SHAMMITTHILAKAN, COCHIN HANEEFA , SAIKUMAR. PLEASE AVOID THIS TYPE OF RUBBISH COMMENTS. EVN KEERTHI CHAKRA HAVING SOME UNNECESSARY MASALA SCENES ( UNNECESSARY RAPE SCENES) AND SOME UNWANTED FIGHTS KEERTHICHAKRA'S TAMIL REMAKE FAILED IN TAMIL BOX OFFICE WHEREAS WHEN NAAIRSAAB DUBBED IN TAMIL, IT WAS BIG HIT. THAT MEANS TAMILANS APPRECIATED JOSHI'S TECHNICAL PERFECTION THAN THAT OF MAJOR RAVI. AND THAT OF MAMOOTY'S ACTING THAN MOHANLAL . EVEN MOHANLAL'S BIBLE SIFY CRITICISED THAT VULGAR RAPE SCENE IN KEERTHICHAKRA

NEW DELHI STORY POLE MATTORU STTOOORY ...
POOYI THOOONGI CHAKEDAAAAAAAAAAAAA NANAMILLATHAVANEEEEEEEEEE..

MAMMUVINTE 2 FILM --MILITORY BACKGROUNDIL EDUTHU ..NAIRSAB / SAINYAM

ONNU HITAAYI --ONNU KEERI PALESAYI ...2 UM MAAS MASALA FILM ..

ATHINEYAANO NEE KEERTIYUMAAYI COMPAIRE CHEYYUNNATHU ..

KEERHTI MASS FILM ALLA . INIYUM NINNOD ENTHELUM PARAYAAN NINNAL-
POTHINTE CHEVIYIL VEDHAM ODUNATHU POLEYAAKUM ..

Patallam can be added too

O ATHU NJAAN VITTUPOOYI

PATTALAM MATHRAM ALLA ..
PUTHAYAL --------------------ENNA PERIL ORU THARA FILM IRANGIYIRUNNU -ATHUM MILITORY ANENNU THOONNUNNU ..
(ATHU KANENDA GATHIKEEDU ENIKUNDAAYILLA )
HO E MAMMU KARANAM PATTALAKARUDE PEERUKOODI ILLATHAKUM ..

Aravind Mohan Krishnan · 09-03-2006, 04:05 PM

Jeeva is not just a 'small' officer. He is the buddy of Major Mahadevan, i.e. 2nd in command of the Black Commando unit.

And as for saying why terrorists are only from Kashmir or Afghanistan, well the film is about the brutal face of terrorism in Kashmir! For that why use other Indian terrorists?

jaseer · 09-03-2006, 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aravind Mohan Krishnan

Jeeva is not just a 'small' officer. He is the buddy of Major Mahadevan, i.e. 2nd in command of the Black Commando unit.

And as for saying why terrorists are only from Kashmir or Afghanistan, well the film is about the brutal face of terrorism in Kashmir! For that why use other Indian terrorists?

AVANOOD ATHONNUM PARANJITU KARYAMILLA ..

AVAN RAJYA SNEHMILLATHAVANANENNU AVANTE DIALOG KETTAL AIRYILLEEEEEEEEEEEE...

AVANUM MATORU INDIAN TERRORIST AANENNU THOONNUNNU ..

KC -KANDITTU ITHUVAREEYUM OTTA MANUSHYAN POLUM MOSHAM ENNU PARANJITILLA ..

--( MANNUNNEES -OZHICHU .VRITHIKETTAVANMAAAAAR .)

GK · 09-03-2006, 04:10 PM

NEW DELHI STORY POLE MATTORU STTOOORY ...
POOYI THOOONGI CHAKEDAAAAAAAAAAAAA NANAMILLATHAVANEEEEEEEEEE..

MAMMUVINTE 2 FILM --MILITORY BACKGROUNDIL EDUTHU ..NAIRSAB / SAINYAM

ONNU HITAAYI --ONNU KEERI PALESAYI ...2 UM MAAS MASALA FILM ..

ATHINEYAANO NEE KEERTIYUMAAYI COMPAIRE CHEYYUNNATHU ..

KEERHTI MASS FILM ALLA . INIYUM NINNOD ENTHELUM PARAYAAN NINNAL-
POTHINTE CHEVIYIL VEDHAM ODUNATHU POLEYAAKUM ..
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SENTENCE TO SENTENCE REPLY-

NEW DELHI STORY POLE MATTORU STTOOORY ----------WHAT'S WRONG WITH NEWDELHI. ITS A BIG HIT

POOYI THOOONGI CHAKEDAAAAAAAAAAAAA NANAMILLATHAVANEEEEEEEEEE---------PLEASE AVOID THIS TYPE OF COMMENT. WHY U ARE MAKING THIS TYPE OF COMMENTS WHEN U ARE NOT HAVING PROPER REPLY TO MY COMMENT

MAMMUVINTE 2 FILM --MILITORY BACKGROUNDIL EDUTHU ..NAIRSAB / SAINYAM ONNU HITAAYI --ONNU KEERI PALESAYI ...2 UM MAAS MASALA FILM .-------------- I THINK U DIONT KNOW THE HISTORY OF MALAYAL CINEMA. NAIRSAAB WAS MEGA HIT AND SAINYAM CONSIDERD AS ONE OF THE HIT. MAMOOTY ALSO ACTED SO MANY TIME AS MILITARY OFFICER, BUTIN SAINYAM HE IS NOT ACTING AS MILITARY OFFICER. HE ACTED IN KODEVIDE, PATTOLAM, MEGAHAM ETC AS MILITARY OFFICER OUT OF WHICH ONLY PATTALAM FAILED TO ATTRACT THE CROWD EVENTHOUGH PATTALAM IS NOT CONSIDERD AS MILITARY MOVIE

ATHINEYAANO NEE KEERTIYUMAAYI COMPAIRE CHEYYUNNATHU .. KEERHTI MASS FILM ALLA . INIYUM NINNOD ENTHELUM PARAYAAN NINNAL POTHINTE CHEVIYIL VEDHAM ODUNATHU POLEYAAKUM -------------ACTUALLY THIS COMMENT IS MORE SUITABLE FOR U .SO IAM STOPPING MY REPLY

-

GK · 09-03-2006, 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aravind Mohan Krishnan

Jeeva is not just a 'small' officer. He is the buddy of Major Mahadevan, i.e. 2nd in command of the Black Commando unit.

And as for saying why terrorists are only from Kashmir or Afghanistan, well the film is about the brutal face of terrorism in Kashmir! For that why use other Indian terrorists?

U PLEASE WATCH THE MOVIE AGAIN. JEEVA'S CARACTER SAYING TO GOPIKA THAT HE WILL MAKE HIS SON AS BIG AND NOT LIKE TAHAT OF HIM A SMALL OFFICER. EVENTHOUGH JEEVA IS BIG OR SMALLIS NOT THE REAL PROBLEM, I MENTIONED THAT ONE FOR REPLYING YOUR WRONG STATEMENT

GK · 09-03-2006, 04:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jaseer

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aravind Mohan Krishnan

Jeeva is not just a 'small' officer. He is the buddy of Major Mahadevan, i.e. 2nd in command of the Black Commando unit.

And as for saying why terrorists are only from Kashmir or Afghanistan, well the film is about the brutal face of terrorism in Kashmir! For that why use other Indian terrorists?

AVANOOD ATHONNUM PARANJITU KARYAMILLA .. :roll:

AVAN RAJYA SNEHMILLATHAVANANENNU AVANTE DIALOG KETTAL AIRYILLEEEEEEEEEEEE... :roll:

AVANUM MATORU INDIAN TERRORIST AANENNU THOONNUNNU .. :twisted: :evil:

KC -KANDITTU ITHUVAREEYUM OTTA MANUSHYAN POLUM MOSHAM ENNU PARANJITILLA .. :wink:

--( MANNUNNEES -OZHICHU .VRITHIKETTAVANMAAAAAR .)
:twisted:

UR COMMENT IS AS FOOLISHNESS LIKE SOME NARROW MINDED POLITICANS ARE SAYING THE PEOPLE WHO SUPPORT PAKISTAN TEAM IS ANTI NATIONALISTS OR TERROSITS. LIKE THATU ARE SAYING PERSON WHO CRITICISING KEERTHICHAKRA IS TERRORISTS. SOME PERSONS ARE SUPPORTING PAKISTAN TEAM DUE TO THEIR PERFORMANCE AND TEAM SPIRIT NOT BECAUSE OF TERRORISTS. SAME APPLICABLE TO KEERTHICHAKRA ALSO JASEER PLEASE CHANGE THIS TYPE OF MENTALITY.